DarbNation

Vids › The Weirdness, Part 1

Nada Surf – Popular

1996 · Directed by Jesse Peretz

117K Likes

Best comments

1.“I'm the most popular person in my mother's basement.”

More comments
  1. 2.“Nada Surf is what you get when you combine Weezer and a debilitating alcohol problem.”
  2. 3.“I remember downloading this video on Napster in 2000 with my 56k connection... took about 6 months.”

The story

The talking parts of Popular aren't even Nada Surf's words. Matthew Caws lifted them from Penny's Guide to Teen-Age Charm and Popularity, a 1964 teen advice book by actress Gloria Winters, and reads them in the flattest, most sarcastic voice he can find. Then the guitars kick the door in. Ric Ocasek produced it at Electric Lady Studios in New York, and it came out in May 1996 as the band's debut single.

Jesse Peretz shot the video at Bayonne High School, with the administration's blessing. The band plays the staff: Caws is the teacher, Daniel Lorca the security guard, Ira Elliot the football coach. A cheerleader takes the teacher's popularity advice a little too literally and dates two football players behind their backs. She was played by Sarah Sebestyen, then 18 and a student at Manhattan's Professional Children's School.

It reached number 11 on Billboard's modern rock chart, spent two weeks at number one in Iceland and went gold in France. It stayed their biggest hit, which is how a 2016 anniversary piece ended up calling them a one-hit wonder. In 2021 the band Pom Pom Squad covered it with Caws on backing vocals and remade the video at the same school. Twenty-five years later, the hallway still needed the warning.

More Rock music vids

  1. 1.Pulp – Common People★ favorite

    295K Likes

    4:05

    Best comments

    1.“Violently British.”

    More comments
    1. 2.“I saw Jarvis in Sainsbury's yesterday. He was with someone, pushing a trolley. I was weirdly disappointed he wasn't inside the trolley.”
    2. 3.“He is so pretty – like if Winona Ryder was a man.”
  2. 2.Unknown Mortal Orchestra – Swim and Sleep (Like a Shark)★ favorite

    64K Likes

    2:46

    Best comments

    1.“That painting is actually pretty realistic, considering how the horse looks.”

    More comments
    1. 2.“Tag yourself – I'm the guy painting 'USB STICK' on a wall.”
  3. 3.Tame Impala – Apocalypse Dreams★ favorite

    3.5K Likes

    5:53

    Best comments

    1.“Probably the craziest acid trip... without the acid.”

    More comments
    1. 2.“I saw this with my mom.”
    2. 3.“Requiem for a Dream, Pulp Fiction, Scarface, American Psycho, Friday, The Big Lebowski, Trainspotting, A Clockwork Orange, Donnie Darko, Pineapple Express... and Ted.”
  4. 4.Grizzly Bear – Ready, Able★ favorite

    59K Likes

    4:32

    Best comments

    1.“My teacher pulled this up in class as an example of stop-motion. We watched about a minute, then she turned it off. The room was dead silent. 'That was weird,' she said.”

    More comments
    1. 2.“Grizzly Bear is your favorite band's favorite band.”
    2. 3.“Radiohead recommended this.”
  5. 5.Tenacious D – Tribute★ favorite

    1.4M Likes

    4:53

    Best comments

    1.“Tribute is the 2nd best song ever – next to whatever they played that night.”

    More comments
    1. 2.“This was my wedding song. True story. Still together.”
  6. 6.Girls – Hellhole Ratrace★ favorite

    9.3K Likes

    6:58

    Best comments

    1.“RIP in peace, Girls – you were my favorite band ever for a while. I haven't enjoyed being sad this much since Psychocandy.”

    More comments
    1. 2.“You don't really get this song until you find yourself at rock bottom.”
    2. 3.“How does this not have a million views?”

Get the essays free

Bi-monthly-ish. Unsubscribe if it sucks.